“The Jewish Community Today is Ailing”

Joe A. Wahed (Z"L) passed away on 12/31/13

Joe A. Wahed (Z”L) passed away on 12/31/13

This past Sunday, the Jewish community of the San Francisco Bay Area said good-bye to one of its most cherished members. Joseph A. Wahed, a Karaite Jew born in Egypt and active member of the Karaite Jews of America, was laid to rest.

As was repeated throughout the funeral, Wahed avoided intra-Jewish polemics and diatribes, and made no distinction in the level of respect he showed Jews of all movements and denominations (Rabbanites, Karaites, Orthodox, Conservative, Reform). Wahed’s attitudes toward his Jewish brethren echoed a letter written by a Rabbanite about 1000 years ago.

In the early part of the 11th century, the city of Fustat (in Egypt) was ridden with Jewish communal strife – strife between Karaites and Rabbanites, and also within the Rabbinic community (which did not hesitate to label its own members as heretics). [1.] In the year 1029, the Rabbanite Shelomo b. Yehuda wrote a letter to his son in Fustat, offering fatherly guidance on how to navigate the communal politics:

“In Fustat, there is fighting between the Rabbanites and Qaraites, and among the Rabbanites [themselves]. . . . Please, please, my son, be careful not to take part in that at all. . . . For the Jewish community [umma] today is ailing [and] needs special care, just as a sick person needs special care.” [2.]

Joe Wahed always gave the Jewish community the special care it deserved. When the Hebrew Immigrant Aid Society (now known as “HIAS”) raised money to help Jews (both Rabbanites and Karaites) leave Egypt and resettle in the United States, Wahed actively urged his Karaite friends to save money to repay the loans they received from HIAS.  Wahed explained that the Jews of Syria were then in need of safe and secure exit from that country, and that the Karaites could and should help. [3.]

Years later, Wahed helped found JIMENA, Jews Indigenous to the Middle East and North Africa, to publicize the plight of Jews who were forced to leave Arab countries after the founding of the State of Israel.

As for me, Wahed’s perspective shaped the tone of this blog greatly. Several years ago, I went on a rant about how the Rabbanites were wrong about something-or-another. Wahed reminded me that we are all Jews, and as Jews it is in our nature to disagree. Then Wahed emphasized how important it is to advocate for my cause without whining or sounding bitter.

I cannot say for sure, but I believe that was my last real anti-Rabbanite rant. I can say for sure that I have adopted his guidance in leveraging A Blue Thread to publicize the Karaite cause.

With Joe Wahed’s passing, the Jewish community today is ailing.  We can only pray that someone will give us the special care we need.

* * *

[1.] Rustow, Marina; Heresy and the Politics of Community: The Jews of the Fatimid Caliphate, p. 174.

[2.] Id. BTW, Shelomo b. Yehudah was among those who opposed the excommunication of Karaites in 1029, as discussed here.

[3.] As relayed by Joseph Pessah, acting rav of the Karaite Jews of America, who presided at the funeral.




Filed under Dr. Rustow, JIMENA, Karaite Jews of America, Karaite Rabbanite Relations

5 Responses to “The Jewish Community Today is Ailing”

  1. Zvi

    This is very lofty. But unfortunately his conciliatory attitude does not suffice to overcome the Rabbinic hostility that animates the oppression of Qaraites in Israel, and the governmental indifference to the Qaraites’ budgetary plight (and the occasional bureaucratic obstacles imposed on the Qaraites) that helps sustain the oppression.

    May his memory be blessed.

  2. Joe was a great man. I recall many wonderful moments listening to Joe talk about politics and economics. He always had something thoughtful to say, even in hard times. Many times he had some funny anecdote to share. He always had a smile and could make you laugh. Is loss has been deeply felt by my small family and he will be missed.

    He was a man of courage. He made certain the the plight of Egyptian Jews was not forgotten. He helped to found JIMENA and tried to raise awareness.

  3. Sha'ul Bentsion

    I’m so sorry for the loss suffered by the KJA community, Shawn. Sounds like he was a wonderful man. 🙁

    May this lesson of unity echo in our hearts, so that through kindness towards one another, we may advance the coming of the Geulah.

  4. Simon

    Barukh Dayan Ha’Emet from the UK!

  5. art phillips

    Mr. wahed was right…as jews we disagree…but even though we disagree ..we are all still brothers …just at different degrees…

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *